When evaluating interventions or strategies for children, it’s important to understand two key concepts: internal validity and external validity. These terms help us determine whether the results of a study or program are trustworthy and meaningful for broader application.
Internal validity refers to how well a study can show that the changes observed in a child’s behavior (dependent variable) are truly due to the intervention (independent variable) and not other factors.
Why it matters: If a study lacks internal validity, it’s hard to know if the intervention worked or if other influences (confounding variables) played a role.
Example: If a child’s anxiety decreases during a study testing a new coping strategy but starts a new medication or experiences a positive life change (e.g., switching to a less stressful school), we can’t be sure the improvement is due to the coping strategy.
External validity is about whether the findings of a study can be applied to other children, environments, or situations outside of the original study.
Why it matters: Even if an intervention works well for one child in a specific setting, we need to know if it will work for other children or in different environments (like home vs. school).
Example: If a study successfully improves classroom behavior in one school, external validity determines whether the same approach would work in another school, with different students, or in a home setting.
🔑Key Differences Between Internal and External Validity🔑
Features | Internal Validity | External Validity |
Focus | Causation: Did the intervention cause the change? | Generalization: Can the results apply elsewhere? |
Importance | Ensures results are accurate within the study. | Ensures findings are useful beyond the study. |
Threats | Confounding variables (e.g., other changes in a child’s life). | Limited sample size or unrepresentative settings. |
Internal Validity: This helps us trust that the intervention is working for the child in the study.
External Validity: This helps us decide if the strategy can be applied to your child or classroom.
When reviewing interventions, it’s important to ask:
Are there other factors that might have influenced the results?
Would this approach work for my child or in my classroom setting?
By understanding these concepts, parents and teachers can make more informed decisions about interventions, ensuring that children receive strategies that truly support their growth and success.
Comments